Skip to content
DIGITAL RIGHTS & COPYRIGHT LAW

Rival Dog Book Publishers Clash in Federal Court Over Alleged Pay-to-Ban Social Media Takedown Scheme

A bizarre and legally uncharted dispute between rival luxury photo book publishers has erupted into a Florida federal lawsuit, laying bare the murky underworld of commercial social media sabotage. At the center of the litigation is a sophisticated cyber-blackmail operation where a hired digital contractor allegedly weaponized copyright strikes and mass reporting tools to destroy a competitor’s online presence while simultaneously attempting to double-cross his clients.

The lawsuit, filed last week by The Everything Editions LLC—which markets high-end, $120 photo books celebrating various dog breeds under the brand name "The Dog Book"—brings unprecedented scrutiny to the booming, clandestine market for social media account takedowns. According to court documents, the bitter feud highlights how automated content moderation policies and rights management systems on platforms like Meta’s Instagram and Facebook can be manipulated not just by scammers, but by commercial vendors offering platform bans as a paid service.

A Dog-Eat-Dog Playbook

Copyright-Strike-for-Hire: Lawsuit Targets Service Over Fake Meta Takedowns

The origins of the federal complaint trace back to a fierce commercial rivalry between The Everything Editions and a competing publisher known as the Remus Collection. Like the plaintiff, the Remus Collection operates in the lucrative niche market of premium $120 dog breed photography books.

The conflict escalated in August when Remus formally accused The Dog Book of copyright infringement, setting off a chain reaction of digital retaliation. In response, representatives for The Dog Book disputed the claims and publicly questioned the authenticity of Remus’s website copy, pointing out potential indicators that the text may have been generated by automated artificial intelligence tools rather than human writers. Ironically, court records note that The Dog Book’s own social media channels have featured images and publications bearing "AI content" labels, though the plaintiff maintains this detail is entirely irrelevant to the core legal grievances.

Rather than addressing the questions regarding its website copy through legal or commercial channels, Remus and its principals allegedly took a more aggressive route. According to the federal complaint, Remus leadership urged their collective Instagram followers to mass-report The Dog Book’s official account under allegations of "scam/fraud." The campaign achieved its intended effect; on September 7, Instagram suspended The Dog Book’s primary account, citing violations of the platform’s account integrity standards.

Lawyers for The Dog Book quickly intervened, issuing a formal cease-and-desist letter. Facing potential legal exposure, a lawyer representing Remus agreed in writing that the rival company and its principals would cease labeling The Dog Book as a fraudulent operation. However, the legal truce proved illusory. The complaint alleges that while the public accusations stopped, a much more insidious, underground attack campaign immediately took its place.

Copyright-Strike-for-Hire: Lawsuit Targets Service Over Fake Meta Takedowns

Monetized Copyright Strikes and Double-Crossing Contractors

As The Dog Book scrambled to establish new Instagram profiles to maintain its customer base and marketing efforts, those replacement accounts were systematically targeted and disabled in rapid succession. The first newly minted backup account was taken down on September 9, just a day after Remus’s attorney had signed the agreement to halt the public smear campaign.

The nature of the attacks shifted significantly in early October, when Meta received a wave of six formal copyright notices targeting specific posts on The Dog Book’s Instagram accounts. The targeted material included standard promotional photographs and videos featuring popular breeds such as Yorkshire Terriers, Dachshunds, Cocker Spaniels, and Jack Russells.

In a bizarre administrative twist that highlighted the automated nature of platform enforcement, the copyright notices were filed under the name of the victimized company itself. Every single takedown notice listed "The dog book" as the asserted rights holder while simultaneously claiming ownership over the bookseller’s own marketing posts. Meta dutifully processed the notices, plunging The Dog Book deeper into operational distress.

Copyright-Strike-for-Hire: Lawsuit Targets Service Over Fake Meta Takedowns

According to the lawsuit, these automated strikes were not executed by Remus directly, but rather by an independent digital contractor operating as a hired gun—an individual who ultimately attempted to play both sides of the feud for financial gain.

In mid-October, a man identifying himself on Facebook as "Ashmit Ashmit" initiated contact with The Dog Book’s remaining digital team. Claiming full responsibility for the copyright strikes that were crippling the accounts, the individual presented an audacious business proposal.

"One guy need to ban your fb and ig both. He his paying me 1k doller. I also strike cpr on your accounts i will take all back and i have a good plan if you agree," the contractor wrote, according to screenshots included in the court exhibits.

The communications subsequently shifted to the encrypted messaging application Telegram, where the contractor operated under the handle "Fix My Brand." The contractor’s unconventional "good plan" required The Dog Book to voluntarily take its own social media properties offline for a brief window. If the publisher complied and went dark for 30 hours, the contractor claimed he would be able to collect his $1.000 fee from his anonymous client and subsequently retract all the pending copyright strikes.

Copyright-Strike-for-Hire: Lawsuit Targets Service Over Fake Meta Takedowns

Playing Along With the Saboteur

Faced with the systematic destruction of their digital storefront, representatives of The Dog Book decided to play along with the saboteur to gather evidence. They temporarily deactivated their pages over a weekend, but the operation quickly unraveled. The contractor complained that the social media pages had been reactivated prematurely, which ruined his alibi and resulted in his client withholding payment.

"You do 18 hour i dont get my payment. Okay if you are not in a mood boss no issue. I will take down your ig now when you get in your mood let me know after your ig burn," the contractor warned in subsequent messages.

During these negotiations, The Dog Book pressed the contractor to reveal the identity of the individuals funding the attack. When the publisher explicitly named Remus and its principals, the contractor cryptically responded "Yes." He later expressed fear that if his primary clients discovered the double-cross, "they will cancle all my deals." To substantiate his claims, the contractor forwarded internal messages originating from the person directing the campaign, which bluntly stated, "THE PAYEMNT IS FOR DEFINTIVE BAN."

Copyright-Strike-for-Hire: Lawsuit Targets Service Over Fake Meta Takedowns

An Ongoing Digital War and Novel Legal Territory

Investigation into the contractor revealed that "Fix My Brand" operates as a commercial vendor specializing in the illicit sale of account suspensions and digital harassment services. The operator maintains a public Telegram channel named "FMB Vault," which boasts nearly two hundred subscribers and openly describes its administrator as a "Specialist in Account Ban + Unban."

Despite the ongoing litigation, The Dog Book claims that the sabotage campaign has continued unabated. In recent weeks, the publisher’s Facebook presence has reportedly been targeted by more than four hundred false user reports alleging the presence of sexually explicit content.

The plaintiff vehemently denies these accusations, emphasizing in the complaint that its digital accounts have never hosted explicit material of any kind. Instead, the pages have exclusively displayed photographs of dogs, promotional imagery from their photographic books, and standard commercial marketing copy designed to drive book sales.

Copyright-Strike-for-Hire: Lawsuit Targets Service Over Fake Meta Takedowns

The lawsuit formally accuses the defendants of Digital Millennium Copyright Act misrepresentation, false advertising, and defamation, among other civil violations. The Dog Book estimates its total financial losses resulting from the coordinated takedown campaign to exceed $600,000.

Because the litigation is in its earliest stages, none of the allegations have been tested or adjudicated in a court of law, and the named defendants have yet to formally appear to enter a defense. Legal experts note that while false copyright claims and coordinated social media blackmail schemes have become an increasingly common plague for digital creators and businesses, this lawsuit appears to mark the first time a U.S. court has been asked to hold an intermediary vendor accountable for selling targeted platform takedowns and suspensions as a commercial service.

Copies of the original complaint and the accompanying legal exhibits, including the disputed copyright notices, Telegram message logs, and Instagram communications, have been filed with the Florida federal court.