The conversation around modern web animation took an intriguing turn recently when Danny Schwartz shared an article from Ashutosh Biswas on the CSS-Tricks Slack channel. The piece, originally published on Frontend Masters, explores how to achieve staggered CSS scrolling animations by combining several emergent CSS features with a remarkably complex formula. Biswas himself readily admits that the resulting algorithm is massive and can look deeply intimidating to developers looking at it for the first time.
That sentiment resonates broadly across the front-end community. When the link first circulated, it was colloquially dubbed "CSS on drugs." While recovering from a serious injury while managing heavy prescription painkillers certainly does little to sharpen immediate code comprehension skills, a thorough review of the underlying math reveals just how elaborate the approach truly is. A fitting meme quickly encapsulates the feeling: a researcher staring intensely at a chalkboard completely filled with dense, labyrinthine equations, labeled with the caption that one is "almost ready to stagger scroll animations."
To be fair to the original author, this complexity is not accidental. Biswas is striving for a thoroughly generic solution—a unified approach that can connect a progress value to an animation, scroll progress, or any other arbitrary input to drive staggering effects in a uniform way. It is entirely possible to dream up advanced scenarios where this level of centralized control makes logical sense. Imagine, for instance, a web-based karaoke machine that displays a bouncing ball over text, incrementally highlighting characters based on a user’s vocal progress measured dynamically through the browser’s native speech recognition API. Running that kind of animation not as a collection of independently timed objects, but as a single predictable, holistic effect driven by one master progress value, could be precisely what a developer ordered. This would theoretically make sense because the staggered animations must remain strictly interrelated, with the overall motion controlled by a custom input that is not natively built into the browser.
However, unlike such hypothetical interactive applications, replacing the passage of time with scroll progress to control visual animations is already a first-class citizen in modern CSS. Web developers may need a much stronger justification to roll out a custom, math-heavy implementation than the standard use cases provided in the initial tutorial.
A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius
Biswas showcases a scroll-driven use case as a prime example of where his custom stagger formula truly shines. Yet, a glaring red flag suggests that developers might be in danger of reinventing capabilities already provided natively by the browser. The official specification for CSS scroll-driven animations explicitly recognizes that shifting an animation’s foundation from time to time to scroll progress fundamentally alters its nature. As Biswas notes, the resulting animation differs from traditional ones because time is removed from the equation entirely. This is hardly a surprise to the creators of the scroll timeline specification, and the Mozilla Developer Network documentation echoes this exact point when introducing scroll timelines.
Furthermore, the documentation notes that standard properties like animation-delay only hold meaningful utility when developers rely on the default, time-based document timeline. Consequently, traditional delays do not affect scroll-driven animations in the same way. To bridge this gap, modern CSS introduced properties like animation-range-start, allowing developers to delay a scroll-driven animation directly relative to scroll progress rather than temporal milestones.
Therefore, while an esoteric and mathematically dense approach might initially appear impressive, it often indicates that a fundamentally simple task is being handled in an unnecessarily convoluted manner. Testing this hypothesis involves taking the original demo and refactoring it to strip away any reliance on custom CSS functions, replacing them instead with native properties like animation-range-start.
Rewriting a Rewrite
The original Frontend Masters demonstration focused on an animated tally of donations located in a site footer. It represents a subtle, effective use of scrollytelling that encourages users to feel invested as the numerical values dynamically reveal themselves on screen. The only minor reservation regarding this specific application is that it risks being overly subtle; if a user scrolls past the element too quickly, the animated entrance of individual digits can occur faster than the human eye can comfortably register. This makes the donation tally an ideal case study for comparing the distinct merits of scroll-driven versus scroll-triggered animations as layout design choices. However, that broader discussion must wait, as the primary objective remains demonstrating how heavily staggered scrolling CSS animations can be dramatically simplified.
Demonstrating this simplification side by side highlights a core philosophy of web development: simplicity remains paramount for the digital landscape being built for future generations. Comparing the complex mathematical equations found in the original source code with a streamlined fork utilizing native range properties reveals a stark contrast. The takeaway is clear that the only real casualty when judiciously excising overly complex code is a persistent headache.
For developers working within Chromium-based environments, examining the refactored code reveals an immediate departure from grand unified theories of staggered scrolling. Instead of a massive abstraction layer, the code addresses the immediate problem using native capabilities. Preserving the original core functionality means users still need to scroll gradually to fully appreciate the nuanced staggered entrance of each element.

A Simplistic Staggering Formula for Math Phobics
Tackling similar layout challenges in previous explorations demonstrates that alternative mathematical approaches can be remarkably concise. By leveraging native features like sibling-index(), developers can seamlessly increment animation-range-start to stagger the delay of fading characters as a user scrolls through a page, avoiding the trap of premature or incorrect abstractions.
When refusing to over-engineer solutions, a single line of CSS can effectively replace a massive formula and extensive explanations while achieving the exact same visual outcome. Using a clean increment for each sibling element based on the total number of characters ensures that animations are choreographed with evenly spaced delays, allowing the final character to complete its entrance precisely when intended within the containment range.
Avoiding Reinventing Easing Functions
Describing the original math-heavy approach as unconventional highlights a recurring phenomenon in software engineering: once a developer reinvents one core browser feature, stopping becomes difficult. It often leads down a path where additional native behaviors must be recreated from scratch. Sure enough, after navigating through custom formulas designed to make scroll timelines function, developers frequently find themselves confronting limitations regarding built-in easing keywords, cubic-bezier curves, or linear functions, forcing them to manually construct custom easing behaviors.
Web developers ideally should not have to shoulder this burden. Despite the word "timing" appearing directly within the property name, official documentation clarifies that the animation-timing-function property operates identically for CSS scroll-driven animations as it does for standard, time-based animations. Practical implementations prove that scroll-driven animations work seamlessly with timing functions, such as utilizing steps() to animate a sprite climbing a ladder in interactive scrollytelling experiences.
The underlying complication in heavily abstracted animation setups is that merging multiple staggered timelines into a single master timeline forces easing functions to apply globally across the entire aggregate effect rather than individually to each targeted element. This is not an inherent limitation or flaw in CSS, but rather the logical consequence of consolidating a holistic effect driven entirely by a single, monolithic progress value.
In Defense of Reinventing the Wheel
To maintain fairness, web history is filled with impressive achievements by developers who successfully reinvented features already provided natively by browsers. These reinventions typically occur because custom implementations unlock granular control that standard APIs cannot yet provide. Prominent examples span across the broader ecosystem, from UI libraries managing DOM updates and virtual reconciliation to specialized text measurement utilities handling line-breaking logic independently of the browser layout engine. Additional examples include custom parsers that construct abstract syntax trees for programmatic CSS analysis, linting, and optimization.
Acknowledging these precedents illustrates that building custom wrappers or alternative implementations for native browser capabilities is not an inherently flawed practice, provided the motivations and trade-offs are clearly understood. After all, modern scroll timelines are themselves simply a native browser standardization of techniques that web developers spent decades manually orchestrating via JavaScript. Nevertheless, refactoring staggered scroll-driven demos demonstrates that heavy abstractions can sometimes amount to over-engineering for straightforward user interface components.
Wrapping Up
Ultimately, discussions sparked by advanced animation techniques open fascinating doors toward linking CSS animation progress to arbitrary, non-standard input values in ways that conceptually mirror scroll timelines. Even early explorations into scroll timelines highlighted the desirability of expanding input controls beyond standard scrollbars, raising possibilities like text input fields driving visual progress as users fill out forms, or dynamic animations responding in real-time to password strength validation schemas.
Leveraging modern community libraries that expose validation states and field properties via custom properties makes connecting interactive metrics to visual styles more convenient than ever. Expanding these concepts to include user navigation progress through multi-step forms, shopping checkouts, or interactive quizzes outlines a compelling vision for future web interfaces.
While custom animation timelines hold the potential to unlock entirely new classes of engaging user experiences, simpler native solutions often provide the most maintainable path forward. Continuing the dialogue around innovative progress inputs and native CSS capabilities will remain central to shaping immersive and performant web applications moving forward.