Skip to content
INTERNET INFRASTRUCTURE & NETWORKS

APNIC Reports Steady Growth in ASPA Adoption as Community Tackles Routing Security Challenges

Internet network operators are continuing to embrace advanced routing security measures, with APNIC reporting a steady increase in the adoption of Resource Public Key Infrastructure (RPKI) Autonomous System Provider Authorization (ASPA) objects. Following the deployment of management support for ASPA objects earlier this year in June, the community has steadily integrated the technology, resulting in 538 ASPA objects currently published under APNIC’s RPKI trust anchor.

As adoption gathers momentum across the region, network engineers and administrators have raised practical implementation questions regarding how the framework operates in complex topological environments. To address these industry inquiries, APNIC hosted a dedicated webinar for its members and the broader Internet community on September 30, titled "Understanding ASPA: The next step in routing security," with a recording made publicly available for operators seeking to bolster their BGP defenses.

Discussions during the event underscored several key operational themes, notably the precise definition of a provider within the ASPA framework, the deployment nuances surrounding Internet Exchange Point (IXP) environments, and the critical importance of balancing validation deployment risks against operational overhead.

Understanding the Definition of a "Provider" in ASPA Architecture

At its core, an ASPA is a cryptographically signed RPKI object that empowers an Autonomous System Number (ASN) holder to formally declare its authorized provider, upstream, or transit ASNs. Network operators leverage this trusted information to validate Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) paths actively. This cryptographic verification process plays a vital role in detecting and preventing route leaks, thereby significantly reducing the risk that forged or malicious routes will be accepted across interconnected networks.

According to the defining parameters outlined in the relevant Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) profile draft, a Provider AS functions as a network that supplies connectivity between disparate networks by delivering transit services to a customer. However, industry discussions have highlighted that many operators encounter ambiguity regarding the scope of this definition.

The essential takeaway for network administrators is that an Autonomous System is officially classified as a provider even if it supplies transit services only on a part-time basis, operates exclusively at specific geographic locations, or handles traffic for only a subset of network prefixes. Common architectural scenarios, such as partial-transit agreements and backup-transit arrangements, fit squarely into this category and require the supporting AS to be explicitly designated as a provider within the relevant ASPA configuration.

Furthermore, provider relationships in modern routing topologies are not inherently unidirectional. It is entirely common for an Autonomous System to act as a customer of another AS for a specific set of prefixes, while simultaneously functioning as a provider for other prefixes. This dynamic is formally categorized as a complex peering relationship under RFC 9234. Within the ASPA ecosystem, each participating AS in such a reciprocal arrangement must appropriately list the counterpart AS as a provider in their respective declarations.

Configuring ASPAs for Internet Exchange Points and Participants

The integration of ASPA records with Internet Exchange Points introduces architectural considerations that depend heavily on whether the IXP route server infrastructure operates transparently or non-transparently. Two distinct configurations dictate how participants must construct their ASPA statements.

In transparent, Layer 2 IXP environments—which represent the most common deployment model—the route server refrains from inserting its own ASN into the AS path of the BGP announcements it forwards to members. Because the route server remains transparent to the path, participants do not list the IXP’s ASN as a provider within their individual ASPAs. Instead, the underlying routing relationships between the individual IXP participants continue to dictate ASPA validation requirements. For instance, if one exchange participant operates as a customer of another participant across the fabric, that customer is obligated to incorporate the provider’s ASN into its ASPA provider list.

Your most pressing questions about ASPA, answered | APNIC Blog

Conversely, non-transparent, Layer 3 configurations require a fundamentally different approach. Layer 3 route servers are frequently utilized to establish reliable connectivity across extensive wide-area networks spanning beyond a single localized switch fabric, typically relying on Internet Protocol or Multiprotocol Label Switching mechanisms. Attempting to manage equivalent wide-area topologies using purely Layer 2 designs often introduces severe operational hurdles, including broadcast storms, Spanning Tree Protocol loops, and significant MAC table scaling challenges.

Within a non-transparent IXP setup, the route server intentionally appends its own ASN to the path of transmitted BGP messages. Consequently, the IXP functionally operates as a direct provider for each participating network. Under this architecture, participants must include the IXP’s ASN within their ASPA provider lists. Meanwhile, the non-transparent IXP itself does not maintain external ASPA providers; its proprietary ASPA record instead contains a provider list featuring a single AS0 entry. This mirrors the established methodology used in Route Origin Authorizations, where an AS0 designation explicitly indicates the absence of any valid origin ASNs for a given prefix.

Mitigating Risks Associated with ASPA Issuance and Validation

As with any cryptographic routing security mechanism, the implementation of ASPAs introduces specific operational risks that require careful mitigation strategies by network engineers.

The primary risk associated with ASPA creation involves misconfiguration. Similar to the potential pitfalls surrounding ROA deployment, an incorrectly configured ASPA can trigger severe unintended consequences for the issuing organization, including the potential invalidation of all valid routing paths involving their customer ASN.

To counteract this vulnerability, portal interfaces such as MyAPNIC incorporate built-in preventative safeguards designed to assist administrators. The system provides intelligent recommendations derived directly from active BGP observations, while proposed ASPA modifications undergo rigorous pre-submission validation checks to ensure they will not inadvertently invalidate existing, operational BGP routes.

Another prominent challenge centers on the operational workload tied to validation deployment timelines. Before an enterprise can safely enable ASPA validation across its infrastructure, operators must thoroughly verify that misconfigured external ASPAs will not disrupt expected connectivity. As the total volume of published ASPAs steadily increases across the global Internet, the manual effort required for ASN holders to audit, verify, and correct potential upstream misconfigurations before enabling validation also expands.

Industry experts emphasize that deploying ASPA validation early serves as an effective mechanism to curb this escalating operational burden. During the earlier stages of technological adoption, when the absolute number of published ASPAs remains relatively contained, external misconfigurations are significantly easier for the community to identify and remediate. Once validation is actively enabled within a network, any subsequent routing issues stemming from newly issued ASPAs can generally be addressed directly and swiftly by the specific ASN holders responsible for those records.

Administrative Workflow and Community Support

For network administrators seeking to establish ASPA records within the APNIC service region, the administrative procedure is integrated into existing resource management platforms. Operators can complete the process by authenticating into the MyAPNIC portal, navigating to the Route Management section, and accessing the Autonomous System Provider Authorization interface. By initiating a new record, entering the required ASN provider details, and submitting the modifications, the request enters a pending review queue. Operators can then thoroughly inspect the pending adjustments before executing a final commit command to publish the ASPA into the RPKI repository.

Because ASPAs remain a relatively nascent component of the global routing security toolkit, Internet registry operators anticipate that further operational inquiries will surface as broader adoption continues and additional network operators activate validation protocols. APNIC has committed to ongoing community support by streamlining the deployment and validation lifecycle, alongside maintaining a comprehensive central frequently asked questions resource to guide administrators through complex routing scenarios.