A Vietnamese court has sentenced 14 individuals who worked on the popular pirate football streaming platform Bún Chả TV, marking the first time prison terms have been handed down since a sweeping government crackdown on digital piracy began earlier this year. Eleven of the defendants received actual prison sentences ranging from eight to twelve months, while three commentators associated with the network were given suspended sentences. Notably, the alleged master organizer of the criminal enterprise does
not appear to be among those currently facing judgment in this specific initial verdict.
The landmark ruling arrives against the backdrop of intense international pressure, most notably from the United States. In May, the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR) initiated a Section 301 investigation into Vietnam, explicitly pointing to the country’s historical failure to properly prosecute online piracy and arguing that previous judicial actions lacked any meaningful deterrent effect. USTR officials highlighted prior cases where defendants caught operating illegal streaming networks walked away with merely suspended sentences and relatively minor financial penalties.
This external scrutiny dovetailed with domestic policy shifts. Just weeks before the USTR launched its formal investigation, Vietnam’s Prime Minister ordered a nationwide crackdown targeting widespread copyright infringement across the digital landscape. Since that directive was issued, several high-profile criminal cases have advanced through the judicial pipeline, including parallel investigations targeting the alleged operators of the anime streaming hub HiAnime and the massive Xoi Lac TV sports streaming network.
Among the primary targets in the crosshairs of law enforcement was Bún Chả TV, a high-traffic portal that systematically broadcast unauthorized feeds of English Premier League and UEFA Champions League matches, complete with custom Vietnamese-language commentary. According to law enforcement estimates, the site drew hundreds of thousands of visits on a daily basis, functioning less like a casual hobbyist project and more like an underground corporate entity.

Investigators who dismantled the operation described a sophisticated organizational structure complete with specialized teams dedicated to programming, live commentary, search engine optimization (SEO), and accounting. Rather than relying solely on direct user subscriptions, the network generated substantial revenue through display advertising and by systematically redirecting its massive audience toward illicit online gambling and betting platforms.
The enforcement hammer dropped on May 15, when tactical police units from multiple provinces coordinated simultaneous raids. Authorities summoned key suspects, executed search warrants at residential properties and workspaces, and seized a physical haul consisting of 38 computers and 42 phones. Less than two weeks later, Vietnam’s Ministry of Public Security formally announced that police forces in Bac Ninh province had filed criminal charges against an initial group of ten suspects tied to the enterprise.
Up to a Year in Prison
That high-profile case has now reached its initial judicial conclusion. In a first-instance ruling reported by local media outlet VTC News, a court in Bac Ninh convicted all 14 defendants on charges of infringing copyright and related rights under Article 225 of Vietnam’s Penal Code.
The severity of the punishment varied according to the individual’s organizational rank and responsibilities within the pirate network. Four defendants, identified as the leaders of the content, programming, and operations teams, received the stiffest penalties handed down in the courtroom, each being sentenced to 12 months in prison. Five additional defendants received ten-month prison terms, while two others were handed eight-month sentences.
In contrast, three individuals who served as the platform’s match commentators avoided physical incarceration entirely. Their ten-month sentences were granted suspended status, allowing them to remain out of prison under court-monitored conditions provided they commit no further offenses during their probationary periods.

Throughout the legal proceedings, all 14 defendants reportedly confessed to the charges and cooperated fully with investigating authorities. Case files compiled by police indicate that Bún Chả TV successfully streamed more than 150,000 professional sports matches over its operational lifespan. Through a combination of programmatic advertising and the promotion of external betting portals, the illegal operation allegedly amassed more than 20 billion dong—equivalent to roughly $760,000 USD—in unlawful profits.
While court verdict reports did not calculate a singular cumulative profit total for the entire conspiracy, they meticulously detailed the illicit financial gains attributed to individual workers and operational units. For instance, the head of the content team allegedly pocketed more than 430 million dong in proceeds, while individual commentators realized illicit earnings ranging from more than 31 million dong up to over 480 million dong apiece, depending on their tenure and popularity on the platform.
‘Strong’ Penalties Signal Enforcement Shift
The outcome of the trial quickly drew international attention from the intellectual property sector. The verdict was highlighted by Rouse, an international intellectual property law firm that officially represents the Motion Picture Association in Vietnam. In an analytical article published on Lexology under the headline “Strong Vietnam criminal penalties,” the firm hailed the court’s decision as another major victory for Vietnam’s evolving legal landscape regarding intellectual property protection.
While accurately noting that the defendants received custodial terms ranging from eight to twelve months, the law firm’s initial summary omitted the detail that three of those sentences were suspended. Nevertheless, Rouse emphasized that the rulings represent a fundamental and aggressive shift in enforcement strategy by Vietnamese authorities. Instead of relying exclusively on preliminary domain blocking and administrative warnings—tactics that critics long argued were easily circumvented—local regulators are increasingly willing to secure actual criminal convictions against the commercial operators behind large-scale piracy syndicates. According to the firm, this aggressive posture is a direct reflection of the mounting pressure applied by Washington following the USTR’s May intervention.
Organizer Not on Trial?

Despite the conviction of 14 individuals who formed the backbone of the streaming site’s daily operations, a significant question mark remains regarding the ultimate leadership of the enterprise. According to the indictment details reported by VTC News, the entire Bún Chả TV operation was directed by Bùi Bá Hiến, an executive who manages and runs a company known as S24. Investigators stated that Hiến personally gave instructions to employees and actively hired collaborators to build, maintain, and monetize the pirate streaming network.
Despite these allegations in the formal indictment, Hiến’s name does not appear among the 14 defendants who stood trial and received sentences in Bac Ninh. Furthermore, the available court reports do not publicly name any of the corporate rightsholders whose exclusive broadcasting rights were infringed upon by the network.
The absence of the alleged ringleader from the dock coincides with parallel law enforcement actions. In September, police in Bac Ninh issued a formal nationwide wanted notice for an individual bearing the exact same name, Bùi Bá Hiến, who serves as the Chief Executive Officer of the esports company Box Vietnam. That executive is likewise facing criminal charges under the exact same copyright infringement statute.
According to reports from local media outlets such as VNExpress, this executive reportedly fled the country on May 13—just two days before police executed their coordinated raids against Bún Chả TV. However, official police and court documentation reviewed thus far has not explicitly confirmed whether the fugitive esports CEO is definitively the same Bùi Bá Hiến referenced as the mastermind in the Bún Chả TV conspiracy indictment.
As Vietnam navigates these high-stakes prosecutions, the international trade community continues to monitor developments closely. The U.S. Trade Representative faces a late-November deadline to issue its final determination under the Section 301 investigation, though provisions exist allowing Washington to extend the review period by an additional three months if deemed necessary. Under current Vietnamese law, copyright infringement offenses carry maximum potential prison sentences of up to three years. Whether the actual prison terms of 8 to 12 months handed down to the Bún Chả TV workers align with the stringent deterrent standards anticipated by trade officials in Washington remains to be seen.