In a significant legal development for digital rights and internet intermediaries in Europe, the Paris Judicial Court has dealt a substantial blow to sports broadcaster beIN Sports. The court has rejected the network’s demands for hefty daily financial penalties against major virtual private network (VPN) providers and content delivery network Cloudflare over alleged non-compliance with site-blocking orders.
The underlying dispute traces back to May, when the Paris Judicial Court issued targeted orders requiring several VPN providers to block ten pirate streaming websites and IPTV services that illegally broadcast Women’s Tennis Association (WTA) matches. Among the targeted platforms were well-known streaming destinations such as thetvapp.to and tennistream.com. These legal actions followed a familiar and increasingly aggressive pattern of enforcement in France, requested primarily by beIN Sports, which holds the exclusive French broadcasting rights for the vast majority of WTA tour matches. Just a day after securing the initial injunctions against the VPN operators, the broadcaster managed to obtain a similar site-blocking order directed at Cloudflare.
When beIN Sports initially brought forward its request in the spring, the network asked the court to impose penalties of 2,000 euros per day for each domain that two specific VPN providers failed to block. At the time, the court declined to impose those fines, noting there was no evidence demonstrating that the providers deliberately intended to flunk compliance. The court indicated that if genuine technical problems arose, the parties could return to present their arguments. That is precisely what transpired.
beIN Loses Penalty Request
As first reported by French tech publication L’Informé, beIN Sports subsequently returned to the Paris Judicial Court, complaining bitterly that the VPN providers and Cloudflare had failed to fully and effectively block the pirate websites. Escalating its demands considerably, the broadcaster requested a staggering daily penalty of 10,000 euros for every single domain that remained accessible to internet users.
The targeted companies—Cloudflare, Surfshark, and Nordvpn—faced the court represented by the same legal counsel. During the hearings, they cited significant technical constraints inherent to their services and maintained that they had acted in good faith, doing their absolute best to comply with the complex court orders. A fourth entity, Proton, was also named in the proceedings but did not make an appearance at the hearing.
An examination of the technical measures implemented by the companies revealed that their blocking efforts were far from bulletproof. Cloudflare successfully blocked three of the four specified sites, but managed to do so exclusively through its Content Delivery Network (CDN) architecture. Meanwhile, Surfshark and NordVPN blocked six out of eleven domains, but restricted their actions solely to the Domain Name System (DNS) services operating on their servers physically located within France.

‘Reasonable Effort’ Standard Prevails
For the Paris judges, the measures implemented by the intermediaries were sufficient under the law. In two separate rulings issued on October 7, the court concluded that internet intermediaries are legally required to make a "reasonable effort" to block infringing sites, but they are under no obligation to guarantee a flawless outcome. This interpretation aligns closely with established case law from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). The case files presented during the proceedings demonstrated that all of the responding companies had carried out the court-mandated orders, at least in part.
"The requested penalty therefore does not appear necessary or proportionate, given the need to strike a fair balance between the protection of the intellectual property rights of copyright and neighboring rights holders, and the freedom to conduct a business enjoyed by economic operators," the court wrote in its decision, as translated and reported by L’Informé.
Despite this setback for the broadcaster, the original site-blocking orders themselves remain fully in effect and will continue to operate until the conclusion of the WTA season, which is currently scheduled for November 14. In the meantime, beIN Sports retains the right to appeal the court’s decision regarding the rejected penalties.
This outcome mirrors a strikingly similar ruling handed down by the same Paris court just last month involving Canal+ and Cloudflare. In that case, Canal+ sought massive daily penalties of 50,000 euros per site against Cloudflare, but the court ultimately refused, concluding that Cloudflare was only obligated to take reasonable measures—an obligation it fulfilled by executing blocks through its CDN.
The legal battles are far from over, and other intermediaries are facing similar pressures. DNS resolver Quad9 is next in line to face the broadcaster’s wrath. According to the Swiss-based foundation, beIN Sports is demanding 10,000 euros per domain, per day, which would accumulate to an astronomical total of 580,000 euros a day. Quad9’s legal position differs fundamentally from the other intermediaries, however, because the organization is not blocking any of the targeted domains at all. A judicial decision regarding beIN’s request against Quad9 is expected later this month.
Appeals Court Hits Pause
The rejection of the penalty requests is not the only obstacle rightsholders have encountered recently in the French courts. The VPN providers are aggressively fighting the underlying site-blocking orders directly, and that broader legal battle has just been granted significant breathing room.
Last year, major VPN operators including NordVPN, Proton, and CyberGhost filed appeals against one of the earliest VPN site-blocking orders, which had been secured by the French professional football league, LFP, back in May 2025.

At the formal request of the VPN providers, the Paris Court of Appeal decided on September 30 to put that specific case on hold. Rather than issuing a ruling on the merits of the appeal immediately, the court elected to wait for France’s highest court of ordinary jurisdiction, the Cour de cassation (Supreme Court), to render a decision on pending appeals concerning seven earlier rulings.
Those earlier rulings, which were issued in March and May of this year, upheld site-blocking orders that Canal+ had successfully obtained against DNS providers. During the March proceedings, tech giants Google, Cloudflare, and Cisco lost their appeals regarding pirate site DNS blocking. Subsequently, several of the affected DNS providers escalated the matter to the Supreme Court.
While the Paris Court of Appeal acknowledged that the current VPN dispute is not identical to the DNS cases, it determined that there is a sufficient degree of legal overlap to justify pausing the proceedings and awaiting clarity from the Supreme Court.
"Despite the differences, namely that the seven decisions under appeal concern DNS providers rather than VPNs, and that they were issued at the request of the Canal Plus companies rather than LFP and LFP1, the present case has many legal questions in common with the rulings under appeal before the Supreme Court," the appeals court noted in its freeze order.
The overlapping legal questions include determining precisely who can be legally ordered to assist in stopping online piracy, examining whether French site-blocking legislation fully complies with broader European Union law, establishing strict standards for how copyright infringements must be legally proven, and defining when blocking measures can be considered proportionate.
Although it remains entirely unknown when the Supreme Court will issue its final rulings on the matter, the Paris Court of Appeal firmly believes that the ultimate outcome will have a profound impact on the ongoing VPN litigation as well. A copy of the Paris Court of Appeal’s ruling under reference RG 25/09229 has been made publicly available as part of the legal record.