WASHINGTON — Senate Commerce Committee Chair Ted Cruz (R-TX) began a high-stakes committee meeting Wednesday meant to confirm President Donald Trump’s nominee to the Federal Communications Commission with a lopsided dais that immediately underscored deepening partisan divisions on Capitol Hill. To Cruz’s right sat all 14 Republican members of the panel, including Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD). To his left were about a dozen empty chairs, as every single Democratic member of the panel stayed away in a coordinated boycott.
Cruz opened the proceedings by noting that he had learned just the previous night that Democrats intended to boycott the vote. In contrast, Democrats maintained that they had repeatedly raised their concerns over the push to advance a Republican FCC nominee without a paired Democratic nomination.
“The administration has shown it’s willing to move Democrats,” Cruz said during the meeting, pointing to scheduled Senate votes on bipartisan pairs of nominations to other independent federal bodies, specifically the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Cruz acknowledged that while the Supreme Court has confirmed the president’s broad legal power to remove independent agency officials, Trump has not moved to fire any sitting Democrats from the FCC, a sharp departure from his actions at the Federal Trade Commission, where Democratic commissioners were ousted.
“This is an ordinary nomination to fill a vacancy previously held by someone in the same party,” Cruz insisted, defending the timeline of the proceedings.
However, in statements issued to the press and comments delivered to reporters outside the committee room ahead of the meeting, Democrats argued that the confirmation process has been anything but normal. Historically, Senate committees have often advanced nominations to historically independent regulatory agencies in bipartisan pairs to maintain a balanced approach to oversight and administration.
The nominee in question, Danielle Thumann Severs—who currently serves as senior counsel to FCC Chair Brendan Carr—has been tapped to become a commissioner at the agency. If confirmed, her addition would bring the FCC to four total active members: three Republicans and one Democrat, Anna Gomez. While Gomez’s official term has technically expired, she is legally permitted to remain on the commission through next year unless she is formally replaced by the White House.
Despite this provision, Democrats have expressed profound fears that confirming a third Republican to the commission would give the GOP a secure majority and clear the way for Trump to finally fire Gomez, since the remaining Republican quorum would be sufficient to conduct official business and vote on key regulatory actions without any Democratic presence.
Seeking to prevent this scenario, Democrats formally asked for Thumann’s confirmation vote to be withheld until her nomination could be appropriately paired with a Democratic nomination. One straightforward way to achieve this balance, they noted, would be to renominate Gomez for another term. Yet, as of Wednesday, the administration had not put forward any Democratic nominees for the commission.
Democrats stated that they made these procedural concerns explicitly clear to Cruz well in advance, characterizing the impasse as an administrative choice rather than a legislative standoff. “This is not a problem we created, but a problem that the White House can solve,” Democrats said in statements. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding the nomination strategy.
Beyond the broader procedural and structural objections, Democratic lawmakers harbor deep concerns regarding Thumann’s past work as an adviser to Chair Carr, particularly questions surrounding whether she was entirely truthful during her confirmation testimony regarding the nature and scope of the matters she handled.
In a formal letter urging Cruz to delay the confirmation vote, Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-NM) detailed a series of alarming discrepancies. Luján pointed out that during her November 10 confirmation hearing, where Thumann answered probing questions from committee members under oath, she explicitly testified that she had “not worked with the Chairman on any media-related issues.”
However, documents later obtained via a Freedom of Information Act request paint a significantly different picture. According to Luján’s letter, the records show that Thumann was closely “looped in” on various high-profile media matters. Specifically, the documents indicate she “helped draft Skydance’s commitments that facilitated the FCC’s approval of the Skydance-Paramount merger.”
Furthermore, Luján wrote that “she also played a role in processing informal complaints related to CBS 60 Minutes’ alleged news distortion and she apparently orchestrated the Commission’s response to consumers regarding the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.”
The FCC did not immediately respond to requests for comment regarding these revelations.
The controversy surrounding the Jimmy Kimmel matter has been a major point of contention within the committee. Even Cruz has previously admitted to holding concerns regarding Carr’s handling of Kimmel’s televised comments, which followed the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
Nevertheless, at Wednesday’s meeting, Cruz struck a supportive tone, stating that he “emphatically agree[s]” that Thumann had successfully resolved any lingering worries about the incident during the confirmation process. He added that his proposed JAWBONE Act—legislation previously passed by the committee—could directly address future First Amendment violations by government agencies, regardless of which party is in power. The proposed bill would empower individuals to sue government officials if they attempt to illegally compel social media or broadcast companies to suppress or remove speech.
Sen. Jerry Moran (R-KS), who had also expressed public concern over the Kimmel incident, echoed Cruz’s sentiment, stating that he found Thumann’s explanations “comforting.” Moran noted that during a phone call earlier that morning, he had expressed his “serious interest in how the FCC protects and promotes free speech, including free speech on broadcast.”
According to Moran, Thumann “was able to satisfy me once again in her answers, including an explanation for her role at the FCC and her lack of engagement on this type of issue as the FCC made decisions.”
The reassurances accepted by Republican senators did little to appease the minority party. Speaking to reporters outside of the hearing room ahead of the gavel, Luján leveled harsh accusations against the nominee, asserting that Thumann had lied directly to the committee.
“The questions that I have is if she was lying about this, what else is she lying about and what else is she hiding?” Luján asked rhetorically.
Luján added that he wants both Thumann and Carr to appear before the committee before the end of the year to answer a new round of pointed questions from lawmakers. When asked directly if he would support utilizing the committee’s subpoena power, or even pursuing impeachment proceedings against Carr if Democrats regain control of Congress next year, Luján did not rule out drastic measures. He noted that his past vote to confirm Carr as a commissioner under President Joe Biden is among his greatest legislative regrets. While he expressed hope that Carr would choose to testify voluntarily, Luján emphasized that “everything should be on the table here to be able to get answers for the American people.”
When the meeting reached its definitive moment of action, the committee proceeded to a vote on whether to advance Thumann’s nomination to the final step of a full vote on the Senate floor. All 15 Republican members present cast their votes as “aye.”
With the unified Republican support, Thumann secured the necessary votes for her nomination to successfully clear the committee and advance to the Senate floor, where it is widely expected to pass strictly along party lines once scheduled by leadership.
As the vote concluded, the committee clerk read aloud the names of the 13 Democratic committee members whose seats remained completely empty. There was no response from the Democratic side of the dais, marking a frosty and deeply divided end to the morning’s proceedings.