Stock perpetual futures will continue trading on regulated U.S. platforms including Kalshi, Coinbase Derivatives, and Bitnomial for the time being, following a federal judge’s decision to deny an emergency bid to halt the products. However, the ruling signals a potential victory down the road for Wall Street-backed challengers who argue that regulators overstepped their statutory authority by approving the novel financial instruments.
U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the temporary restraining order following a teleconference with the involved parties. The decision came just hours after the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) formally confirmed that the products were permitted to begin trading on domestic, regulated exchanges.
The legal challenge was initiated by the Capital Markets Alliance Association, a New York-based nonprofit whose membership includes major traditional financial institutions and market makers such as Cboe Global Markets, Citadel Securities, and the Healthy Markets Association, according to a declaration filed by the group’s secretary, Adam Ford.
The alliance filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against the CFTC and Chairman Michael S. Selig, seeking to completely invalidate the approvals granted to the three exchanges. The case, designated as No. 1:26-cv-09608, puts the spotlight on regulatory boundaries between federal agencies and the fast-evolving landscape of modern derivatives trading.
In her written opinion, Judge Caproni stated that the alliance “is likely to succeed on the merits” of its core argument: that the agency lacks the statutory authority to allow perpetual derivatives on individual stocks to be offered to retail investors on platforms regulated primarily by the CFTC.
Elaborating on the legal mechanics, she wrote that because perpetual contracts lack an expiration date, they “by definition, do not provide for a ‘sale for future delivery of a single security.’” Consequently, she reasoned, they cannot properly be classified as security futures over which the CFTC holds statutory and regulatory jurisdiction.
Instead, Judge Caproni noted that the contracts “appear to satisfy the definition of a swap,” a classification that would place them under the regulatory purview of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
Furthermore, the judge found that the balance of equities and the broader public interest favored the alliance at this stage, observing that the agency’s administrative actions “seem to represent a major disruption to the equities market.”
Despite finding merit in the plaintiffs’ core arguments, the emergency request ultimately failed on a single legal prong. Judge Caproni ruled that the declarations submitted by Cboe, Citadel Securities, and the Healthy Markets Association were “conjectural” regarding the specific harms their members would suffer and failed to demonstrate irreparable harm that was both “actual and imminent.”
What the Ruling Does and Does Not Do
The immediate effect of the order leaves the regulatory approvals intact, allowing trading to proceed without immediate judicial interference. Crucially, the ruling does not constitute a final decision on the underlying lawsuit, nor does it resolve the alliance’s separate motion for a preliminary injunction.
The procedural schedule moves quickly. The CFTC’s formal opposition is due by Friday, November 6, while the alliance’s reply brief is scheduled for Tuesday, November 10. The court’s order notes that this timeline remains subject to adjustments by the assigned judge. According to the federal docket, the case is overseen by Judge Lorna G. Schofield.
Despite the ongoing litigation, exchanges wasted little time moving forward. Kalshi was already actively listing four single-stock perpetual contracts tied to Qualcomm, McDonald’s, Amgen, and Costco by Wednesday morning, offering a maximum leverage of 4.9 times.
Legal observers, including reporting from Bloomberg Law, noted that the judge’s preliminary remarks strongly signaled she might ultimately side with the traditional Wall Street firms opposing the introduction of these products.
A CFTC-SEC Turf Fight with Crypto Venues in the Middle
At the heart of the dispute is a fundamental disagreement over regulatory classification and nomenclature. Chairman Selig’s statement maintained that the contracts were deemed approved under Commission Regulation 40.3 as security futures products—a hybrid category jointly overseen by the CFTC and the SEC. The exchanges submitted their filings on September 18, and the agency permitted its standard 45-day review period to lapse without issuing a formal written order.
The Capital Markets Alliance Association contends that any financial contract featuring no expiration date and no physical delivery obligation functions structurally as a security-based swap. Under federal law, Congress explicitly restricted retail trading in such instruments to national securities exchanges operating under the full, undivided oversight of the SEC.
The group’s complaint asserts that the CFTC has effectively “invited a parallel, synthetic market in U.S. stocks to grow outside the exclusive jurisdiction” of the SEC.
A CFTC spokesperson strongly criticized the legal challenge, calling the lawsuit “troubling” and telling Reuters that domestic markets “should be governed by law, not litigation campaigns intended to block innovation.”
For crypto-native trading venues, the stakes of this jurisdictional battle extend far beyond traditional equities. Perpetual futures represent the absolute core product of the digital asset derivatives market, and platforms like Kalshi and Coinbase have increasingly relied on the CFTC’s regulatory framework to bring these popular offshore trading structures onshore.
The agency previously approved the first U.S.-listed bitcoin perpetual contract on May 29, leading Kalshi to launch the product shortly thereafter.
That initial approval is already facing separate legal challenges. CME Group filed a lawsuit against the CFTC in June, arguing that a contract constructed around exchanged funding payments is legally a swap rather than a future. That federal case remains pending in Washington.
While the New York federal court’s latest order specifically covers security futures rather than commodities like bitcoin, a federal judge has now formally established a preliminary view that a financial contract lacking an expiration date does not conform to the traditional legal definition of a future.