Arthur Hayes, the co-founder and former chief executive officer of crypto derivatives pioneer BitMEX, has admitted to feeling “flattered” by Coinbase’s recent legal maneuverings in a high-stakes US courtroom showdown involving stock perpetual futures. The ongoing legal battle marks a significant turning point for a financial instrument that was once heavily scrutinized and marginalized by American regulators when it was first introduced to the broader digital asset ecosystem nearly a decade ago.
Speaking with industry media, Hayes reflected on the evolution of regulatory sentiment surrounding the innovative trading mechanism. When BitMEX originally launched the perpetual swap contract back in 2016, the reaction from Washington, D.C., financial watchdogs and policymakers was notably hostile. The product allowed leveraged speculation on underlying assets without the encumbrance of a fixed expiration date, a feature that eventually revolutionized digital asset trading and became a core liquidity driver across the entire crypto economy.
Now, nearly ten years later, major regulated entities in the United States are actively fighting in federal court to defend the right to offer remarkably similar products tied to traditional equities. Commenting on this shift in the regulatory and corporate landscape, Hayes remarked that imitation is the sincerest form of regulation, underscoring how far the industry has traveled from the days of outright regulatory hostility to mainstream institutional adoption.
The controversy centers around a legal brief submitted on Monday by Coinbase alongside five other prominent industry firms. The coalition formally opposed a request brought forward by an alliance of traditional market participants to block trading in perpetual futures contracts tied to individual corporate stocks. The presiding federal court accepted the amicus-style brief on Tuesday, officially incorporating the exchange giants into the unfolding judicial discourse.
The lawsuit itself was initiated by the Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA), which contends that these novel perpetual contracts should be classified under the strict regulatory framework of security-based swaps. Under existing US financial statutes, security-based swaps face much tighter regulatory oversight, heavier reporting burdens, and significantly restricted access for everyday retail traders compared to standard futures products overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
During his tenure at the helm of BitMEX, Hayes spearheaded the rollout of the groundbreaking Bitcoin perpetual swap. By enabling market participants to maintain leveraged long or short positions on Bitcoin indefinitely without needing to roll over expiring contracts, the product solved major liquidity frictions inherent in traditional futures markets. The success of the perpetual swap transformed it from an experimental derivative into the undisputed lifeblood of modern cryptocurrency exchange volumes.
SEC Weighs in on Stock Perpetuals
The legal battlefield expanded further when the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) reportedly submitted a proposed court brief on Monday. The regulatory agency weighed in to oppose the CMAA’s urgent request to temporarily halt trading activities in the contested stock perpetual contracts.
In its filing, the SEC noted that it is actively reviewing the internal exchange rules governing the listing and execution of these contracts. However, the agency’s brief deliberately left open the critical question of whether the SEC will ultimately choose to set those rules aside or how precisely these perpetual products should be categorized under federal law—specifically, whether they qualify strictly as traditional security futures or as security-based swaps subject to distinct regulatory oversight.
The CMAA fired back in a subsequent court filing on Tuesday, arguing that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission had rubber-stamped the approval of the contracts without providing an adequate explanation for its decision-making process or addressing deeply rooted, unresolved regulatory ambiguities. Furthermore, the alliance pointed to substantial commercial impact, highlighting approximately $375 million in reported 24-hour notional trading volume generated by Kalshi’s stock perpetual products shortly after their market debut. The association argued that these staggering figures demonstrate that the products are already actively diverting business, liquidity, and capital away from traditional stock exchanges.
Stock Perpetuals’ Lack of Expiry Is at Issue
At the absolute center of the legal dispute is the defining characteristic of perpetual contracts: their complete lack of a fixed expiration or delivery date. Unlike conventional futures contracts, which compel market participants to settle or roll over their positions at specific calendar intervals, stock perpetuals allow traders to speculate indefinitely on individual share prices without ever taking physical delivery or owning the underlying equities.
On November 3, US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the CMAA’s initial motion seeking a temporary restraining order against the contracts. The judicial decision rested on the finding that the alliance had failed to adequately demonstrate the likelihood of sustaining immediate and irreparable harm. Nevertheless, Judge Caproni acknowledged that the plaintiff association had shown a reasonable likelihood of succeeding on its core legal claim that the CFTC may have exceeded its statutory authority in approving the products.
Market analysts and legal experts have pointed out that the unconventional structure of perpetual contracts creates significant hurdles for traditional regulatory definitions. Wojciech Kaszycki, a strategy adviser to BTCS SA, noted that the absence of a fixed expiration or delivery date fundamentally complicates the legal argument over whether perpetual contracts can properly be classified under standard definitions of a sale for future delivery.
Kaszycki observed that while traditional jurisprudence struggles to neatly categorize perpetual instruments, a judicial ruling that goes against the CFTC could produce unintended consequences. Rather than eliminating the products, a heavy-handed domestic restriction could simply incentivize trading activity to migrate toward offshore jurisdictions and decentralized platforms operating outside the reach of American courts. Warning about the stubborn resilience of financial innovation, Kaszycki emphasized that the product does not simply die when blocked by regulators; instead, it merely changes its address.