Skip to content
CRYPTO & DECENTRALIZED TECH

S&P Global Ratings Keeps Tether’s USDt at Lowest Stability Score Amid Rising Exposure to Riskier Assets

S&P Global Ratings has opted to maintain Tether’s USDt at the absolute lowest level on its dedicated stablecoin stability scale. The rating agency’s decision comes as higher-risk and more volatile assets continue to take up an increasingly large share of the token’s overall reserves, raising fresh questions about transparency, regulatory oversight, and potential vulnerability to sudden market downturns.

In a comprehensive report published on November 18, S&P evaluated USDt’s fundamental ability to consistently hold its vital one-to-one United States dollar peg and scored the token at 5, which represents a "weak" assessment. This latest evaluation leaves the stablecoin’s score entirely unchanged from its previous standing in November 2025, signaling that ongoing concerns regarding the composition of Tether’s balance sheet have not sufficiently abated in the eyes of traditional financial analysts.

According to the data cited in the assessment, higher-risk holdings—a category that explicitly includes gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans, and various corporate bonds—accounted for approximately 28% of the total USDt in circulation as of September 30. This figure marks a noticeable upward trajectory when compared to the 24% recorded exactly one year earlier.

S&P warned in its report that this mounting exposure to market-sensitive instruments creates a clear vulnerability for the world’s largest stablecoin. "A significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized," the rating agency explicitly noted, highlighting the inherent risks of blending traditional currency backing with more volatile alternative assets.

In response to the report, Tether firmly pushed back against the methodology used by the traditional credit rating firm. Speaking directly to media outlets, the stablecoin issuer argued that the fundamental issue lies with the rating agency’s framework rather than the actual safety or health of its reserves. Pointing to the broader history of traditional financial rating agencies, Tether drew a stark comparison to the corporate blindness that preceded the 2008 global financial crisis, famously depicted in the film The Short.

Despite the ongoing criticism regarding its asset allocation, Tether’s own September 30 reserve report, which was independently attested by accounting firm BDO, painted a picture of robust nominal excess. The report detailed approximately $191.5 billion in total assets against roughly $183.5 billion in corresponding liabilities. This balance left the company with approximately $7.95 billion in excess assets, providing a substantial financial buffer above the total value of USDt tokens in active circulation.

However, S&P noted that while it had identified various additional structural and operational weaknesses during its review, it ultimately made no downward adjustment to the final score simply because "our assessment cannot be lower than 5."

Tether invokes The Big Short in swipe at S&P over USDT reserve risks

S&P Questions Reserve Oversight Safeguards

Among the core vulnerabilities highlighted in the November 18 report are deep-seated concerns regarding the regulatory oversight framework in El Salvador, the jurisdiction where Tether officially relocated its operational base in January 2025.

According to the S&P evaluation, the National Commission of Digital Assets of El Salvador (CNAD)—the primary regulatory body tasked with supervising Tether within the country—mandates that at least 70% of the company’s total reserves must be held in assets capable of being liquidated within a 30-day window. S&P characterized this regulatory framework as remarkably broad, pointing out that such flexibility allows the stablecoin issuer to incorporate relatively high-risk assets, such as gold, Bitcoin, and secured loans, directly into the pool of assets backing the short-term liquidity needs of the token.

Furthermore, the rating agency pointed out a distinct lack of legal requirements to cleanly segregate reserve assets from the broader corporate holdings of the issuer, a standard structural protection that is routinely expected by regulatory bodies in major financial jurisdictions such as the United States and Europe. Because there is currently no publicly available information detailing how these reserves are segregated, the report stresses that external observers and market participants have virtually no insight into how the backing assets are legally insulated from wider corporate risks or potential legal liabilities facing the parent company.

Audit Disclosure Remains a Concern

The debate over transparency and institutional reporting standards also took center stage in the latest review. In August 2026, Tether announced that accounting firm KPMG had confirmed issuing an unqualified opinion on the company’s 2025 financial accounts, marking what the stablecoin issuer celebrated as its first "full independent audit." Executives at Tether repeatedly highlighted this milestone as definitive proof of the health and accuracy of the financial statements issued by the company.

However, S&P stated that these audited statements and the corresponding independent auditor’s report have not been made publicly available for external review, which severely limits the agency’s ability to independently verify the underlying information. Additionally, the rating agency pointed out that Tether’s regular reserve reports continue to withhold the names of the specific financial institutions, custodians, and counterparties that hold and manage the stablecoin’s diverse assets. S&P also noted that these reserve attestations remain restricted to a quarterly schedule, whereas many competing stablecoins have transitioned toward more frequent monthly reporting cycles.

The relationship between Tether and traditional credit rating institutions has long been marked by public friction. At the time of S&P’s initial downgrade of USDt in 2025, Tether leadership openly disputed the findings. Chief Executive Officer Paolo Ardoino took to social media platform X to express defiance, writing that the company "wear[s] your loathing with pride" and pointing to historical financial system collapses as empirical proof that traditional banking and rating frameworks are fundamentally broken.

Despite keeping the stability rating firmly anchored at the lowest possible tier of 5, S&P concluded its November 18 report by acknowledging a notable operational success for the issuer: Tether has maintained a strong historical track record of consistent price stability, successfully defending its peg, particularly over the preceding 12 months of trading.